Address
{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.text}} {{region}} Change location{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.successMessage}} {{region}} Change location Address
{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.text}} {{region}} Change location{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.successMessage}} {{region}} Change locationMember and guest login
Enter your email and password to access secured content, members only resources and discount prices.
Did you become a member online? If not, you will need to activate your account to login.
If you are having problems logging in, please call HIA helpdesk on 1300 650 620 during business hours.
Forgotten password
Need some help?
If you are having problems logging in, please call HIA helpdesk on 1300 650 620 during business hours.
If the email address you have entered is registered, you will receive an email with further instructions.
Become part of the HIA community
Enables quick and easy registration for future events or learning and grants access to expert advice and valuable resources.
Create a guest account
Enter your details below and create a login
Competition law, collective bargaining and contractors
This policy outlines HIA's opposition to access to collective bargaining by small business and independent contractors.
Thursday, 14th May 2020
HIA’s Position statement
- HIA opposes collective bargaining by independent contractors and small business under competition laws, workplace laws and commercial laws. Such arrangements:
- can be anticompetitive
- risk treating contractors as employees
- risk confusing the independent status of contractors
- can threaten housing affordability
- can invite collectivism and interference in commercial and contracting arrangements and
- encourage/enable union participation in the residential building industry.
Background
- Traditionally collective bargaining has only been lawful when exercised by employees in the context of the industrial relations system through unions.
- Collective bargaining by employed workers is not subject to the Competition and Consumer Act (CCA). On the other hand, contractors and other small businesses are subject to the anti-competitive conduct provisions of the legislation. These prohibit price fixing, cartels and other behaviour that would substantially lessen competition.
- In order to be able to use collective bargaining, contractors and small businesses can seek prior approval from the ACCC, which considers the public benefits against public detriment.
- It is argued that collective bargaining allows firms to share these negotiating costs, improving the level of negotiation and achieving outcomes that would not have otherwise been achieved, while also addressing an imbalance in bargaining strength.
- However, this increases the potential for anti-competitive coordination between members of the bargaining group, creating distortions that can harm competitor businesses that are not part of the bargaining group.
- The efficiency created by independent contracting is a key strength of the residential building industry, and if trade contractors were to be able to routinely collectively bargain, there would be an adverse impact on not only contractor independence, but also housing affordability.
Policy endorsed by HIA National Policy Congress: May 2014; Re-endorsed 2020.
Share with your network:
More articles on:
Find the latest expert advice, guides and much more!
Was this page helpful?
Thank you for submitting your feedback.
HIA Advocacy
15 Jan
Response to the Inquiry into the Free TAFE Bill 2024
HIA provided a response to the Senate Education and Employment Committees on the inquiry into the Free TAFE Bill 2024.
09 Jan
Revenue Legislation Amendment Bill 2024 (Qld)
HIA provided a submission on the Revenue Legislation Amendment Bill 2024 to the State Development, Infrastructure and Works Committee.
13 Dec
Unfair Trading Practices Consultation
HIA provided a submission referring to the November 2024 Unfair Trading Practices - consultation of the design of proposed general and specific prohibitions paper produced by Treasury.
13 Dec
Consultation on the impacts proposed WEL for silica
HIA provided a submission to Safe Work Australia (SWA) in response to the consultation on the impacts of the proposed introduction of a new workplace exposure limit for respirable crystalline silica.
11 Dec
Government Business Governance Reform Draft Plan Consultation (Tas)
The Housing Industry Association takes this opportunity to comment on the Government Business Governance Reform Draft Plan.
27 Nov
HIA Submission to the Review of the Home Building Compensation Fund (HBCF)
HIA provided a feedback on the Review of the Home Building Compensation Fund (HBCF) announced by the State Insurance Regulatory Authority (SIRA) in October 2024.