Address
{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.text}} {{region}} Change location{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.successMessage}} {{region}} Change location Address
{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.text}} {{region}} Change location{{propApi.title}}
{{propApi.successMessage}} {{region}} Change locationMember and guest login
Enter your email and password to access secured content, members only resources and discount prices.
Did you become a member online? If not, you will need to activate your account to login.
If you are having problems logging in, please call HIA helpdesk on 1300 650 620 during business hours.
Forgotten password
Need some help?
If you are having problems logging in, please call HIA helpdesk on 1300 650 620 during business hours.
If the email address you have entered is registered, you will receive an email with further instructions.
Become part of the HIA community
Enables quick and easy registration for future events or learning and grants access to expert advice and valuable resources.
Create a guest account
Enter your details below and create a login
Demerit points system for licensing
This policy sets out that HIA opposes demerit points systems in respect to builder licensing, as they are inherently flawed, arbitrary, provide a disproportionate response to offences and may affect those associated with a business.
Sunday, 10th May 2020
HIA's Position statement
- HIA strongly opposes demerit points systems as the systems:
- are inherently flawed
- will operate arbitrarily and unfairly
- will provide a disproportionate response to the nature of the offences incurred
- may have a significant detrimental effect on a licensee’s employees and subcontractors and
- will present and give rise to an uninsurable risk for private insurers.
- On the basis of Recommendation 1, HIA strongly opposes any system that:
- removes judicial discretion to review the decision to suspend or cancel a licence through limiting any assessment to purely quantitative and objective criteria (i.e. has the number of points been reached?)
- seeks to reverse the onus of proof from the regulating body to the contractor and
- has an arbitrary limit on the number of allocated demerit points regardless of activity.
Background
- A demerit point system is similar to a driver’s licence system, where a licence holder has a demerit over a set period of time. There are certain offences where a licensee will incur demerit points. If the licensee accumulates demerit points to the threshold within the period of time, the licensee may lose the right to hold the licence.
- A significant issue with a demerit point system is its potential to impact directly on the licensee’s livelihood.
- The reasons for the development of the demerit point system relate more to easing the administrative effort of regulating bodies than matters of significant non-compliance.
- Demerit points are imposed administratively (subject to appeal) for specified (often low grade) offences. When the licensee’s demerit points reach a certain threshold the consequences are automatically triggered – in the case of the present system in Queensland – without further right of appeal.
- A person may have a licence cancelled or suspended based on the mathematical formula without the regulatory body having to show that the licensee is, in fact, not fit and proper to hold a licence.
- Due to the automatic consequence of reaching the threshold, and its corresponding impact on a person’s livelihood, any demerit points system will need to have appropriate checks and balances to ensure that there a sufficient degree of natural justice and equity for the affected licence holders.
Policy endorsed by HIA National Policy Congress: March 2004; Re-endorsed May 2015; Amended 2020.
Share with your network:
More articles on:
Find the latest expert advice, guides and much more!
Was this page helpful?
Thank you for submitting your feedback.
HIA Advocacy
31 Jan
2025-2026 Pre-Budget Submission - Let's Build
HIA’s 2025-2026 Federal Pre-Budget Submission includes a comprehensive suite of measures to support the industry substantially boost the supply of housing, address the significant skills shortages hampering the industry’s capability and targeted funding to get homes shovel ready sooner.
17 Jan
Homes for NSW Plan
HIA has read with interest the Homes for NSW Discussion Paper, and particularly the intention to deliver more and better homes and develop a system that is flexible enough to respond to emerging needs and new approaches.
17 Jan
Building and Construction Industry Review Discussion Paper (SA)
HIA takes this opportunity to respond to the Building and Construction Industry Review Discussion Paper.
15 Jan
Response to the Inquiry into the Free TAFE Bill 2024
HIA provided a response to the Senate Education and Employment Committees on the inquiry into the Free TAFE Bill 2024.
09 Jan
Revenue Legislation Amendment Bill 2024 (Qld)
HIA provided a submission on the Revenue Legislation Amendment Bill 2024 to the State Development, Infrastructure and Works Committee.
13 Dec
Unfair Trading Practices Consultation
HIA provided a submission referring to the November 2024 Unfair Trading Practices - consultation of the design of proposed general and specific prohibitions paper produced by Treasury.